DuHocNgonNgu.comDu Học Ngôn Ngữ
The science of language acquisition

The cognitive benefits of bilingualism: Bialystok, the critiques and what still holds up

Does being bilingual make children smarter? From Peal and Lambert in 1962 and Bialystok to the critiques about publication bias: which benefits have evidence and which are still open.

The cognitive benefits of bilingualism: Bialystok, the critiques and what still holds up

The clearest benefit of bilingualism is the ability to use two languages itself: to study, work and connect with more people and more sources of knowledge. The idea that bilingualism helps children concentrate better and switch between tasks faster, the so-called "bilingual advantage" in executive function, is a fiercely debated topic: the first studies gave positive results, while recent meta-analyses show a much smaller effect, or none clearly, once publication bias is taken into account.

Parents often come across the phrase "bilingualism helps the brain develop" in descriptions of courses. It is not exactly wrong, but it lumps together claims with very different levels of evidence. This article goes through the history of the topic, sorts each claim by its level of evidence, and points out what applies to a child aged 8–17 who is learning an additional language.

From "bilingualism is harmful" to "bilingualism is beneficial"

In the first half of the 20th century, many studies in the United States and Europe concluded that bilingual children had lower intelligence scores than monolingual children. In hindsight, these studies had serious methodological flaws: they compared poor immigrant children with better-off local children, tested them in a language the children had not yet mastered, and did not control for family circumstances. The conclusion that "bilingualism is harmful" was largely a conclusion about poverty and the language barrier in the tests.

The turning point usually cited is the 1962 study by Elizabeth Peal and Wallace Lambert in Montreal. The two authors selected balanced bilingual children, that is, children fluent in both French and English, and compared them with monolingual children from similar backgrounds. The result: the bilingual children did better on many tests, especially those requiring flexible thinking. This study opened the way to a positive view, although it had its own limits; for example, selecting balanced bilinguals may have meant selecting children who were already highly able.

From the 1980s, the psychologist Ellen Bialystok of York University in Toronto led a long research programme on bilingual children, with her 2001 book Bilingualism in Development as a landmark. The central hypothesis: bilinguals constantly have to manage two languages that are both active in their heads, choosing one and inhibiting the other, so their attention control mechanisms get regular practice.

What Bialystok and her colleagues reported

This research programme produced many results, widely quoted in popular books and in education marketing. The main results:

  • Language awareness: bilingual children understand early that the name of an object is a convention that can be changed, and they do better on grammaticality judgement tasks involving sentences that are grammatical but meaningless. This is the least disputed part.
  • Attention control: on tasks that require ignoring distracting information, such as sorting cards by one rule and then switching to another, bilingual children in the early studies performed better.
  • In older adults: a study by Bialystok, Fergus Craik and Morris Freedman in Neuropsychologia in 2007, based on patient records at a memory clinic in Toronto, found that bilinguals were diagnosed with dementia about four years later than monolinguals.
  • An explanation in terms of cognitive reserve: bilinguals' brains are not less affected by disease, but they may be able to compensate for longer before symptoms show. This is a hypothesis, not a proven mechanism.

A point to note: the results in older adults come from observational data, not experiments. The bilinguals in the sample may differ from the monolinguals in many other ways, such as occupation, place of origin and lifestyle, and the authors tried to control for some of these factors. Some studies elsewhere found similar results; some did not.

The critiques: why the bilingual advantage has been called into question

Large studies could not replicate it. In 2013 Kenneth Paap and Zachary Greenberg published in Cognitive Psychology a series of studies with many measures of executive function and found no consistent advantage in bilinguals. The title of the paper said plainly that there was no coherent evidence. Paap and his colleagues have since continued to be the main critics.

Publication bias. In 2015 Angela de Bruin, Barbara Treccani and Sergio Della Sala, in Psychological Science, compared conference abstracts with what was later published as journal articles. Studies supporting a bilingual advantage were published far more often than studies that found no advantage. This means the published literature may make the effect look bigger than it really is.

Meta-analysis with correction. A meta-analysis by Minna Lehtonen and colleagues in Psychological Bulletin in 2018, pooling many studies of adults, concluded that after correcting for publication bias there was no longer solid evidence of a bilingual advantage in executive function.

Bilinguals are not a uniform group. Supporters respond that "bilingual" covers many kinds of people: those who learned young or later, who use both languages daily or occasionally, who switch languages often or keep them separate. The advantage, if it exists, may appear only in some kinds of bilingualism. This is where the debate stands now.

Sorting the claims by level of evidence

The table below sorts common claims about bilingualism by the evidence currently available, as generally understood among researchers. The classification is a broad assessment and may change as new research appears.

ClaimLevel of evidenceNotes
Learning two languages does not make children less intelligent or cause language disordersSolidThe old "harmful" results were due to flawed methods
Bilingual children understand the conventional nature of language earlierFairly solidDirectly related to using two languages
Knowing another language widens opportunities for study, work and relationshipsSelf-evident, no neuroscience neededThis is the main reason to learn a foreign language
Bilingualism improves executive function in children and adultsDisputed; the effect is small or absentPublication bias, hard to replicate
Bilingualism delays the onset of dementiaSome signal, no conclusion yetObservational data, mixed results
A language course of a few weeks creates a "bilingual brain"No basisThe studies are about long-term, regular bilingualism

The last row is the one most open to misuse. Research on cognitive benefits, whether supportive or critical, is about people who use two languages regularly over many years. No study has shown that a short course produces similar cognitive changes.

Kuhl and research on the brains of young children learning two languages

Another line of research, less disputed, studies how young children's brains process speech sounds, associated with Patricia Kuhl's team at the University of Washington. These studies show that newborns can hear the differences between the sounds of all languages, then during the first year gradually specialise in the sounds of the languages around them. Children who grow up with two languages keep the ability to distinguish the sounds of both.

A well-known study by Kuhl, Feng-Ming Tsao and Huei-Mei Liu in PNAS in 2003 exposed 9-month-old American babies to Mandarin through play sessions with Mandarin speakers; this group kept the ability to distinguish Mandarin sounds, while groups that only watched video or listened to audio recordings did not. The result is often used to argue that social interaction matters for sound learning in young children.

For children aged 8–17 these studies do not apply directly, since they are about the first year of life. What does carry over is the general principle: learning a language through real people, in meaningful interaction, is more effective than learning one-way from a machine. And the phrase "learning two languages makes the brain different" should be read as the brain adapting to using two languages, not as a claim about intelligence.

So what should parents think when their child learns another language?

Good reasons to have your child learn more English or Chinese are the benefits that are not in dispute: being able to read original materials, study in an international environment, work with people from many countries, and understand another culture from the inside. These are major benefits, and they grow with proficiency, regardless of whether the executive function advantage is real.

When you come across a course description built on claims about the brain, such as "raises IQ" or "doubles development", you can ask: which study, on whom, measured how? If the answer is the name of a university and a year, without the name of an author or a journal, that is usually a sign that the source has not been checked.

Finally, keeping your child's Vietnamese while they learn another language is supported by research: reading comprehension and academic thinking skills built in the mother tongue carry over to the second language, as Jim Cummins described in his linguistic interdependence hypothesis from the late 1970s. Bilingualism, in its most practical sense, means gaining a language, not swapping one for another.

Four questions for checking a claim about the bilingual brain

When you read a sentence like "research shows bilingual children concentrate better", you can check it quickly in the following order, based on the very problems that the debate over the bilingual advantage has brought to light:

  1. Who was studied? Children who grew up with two languages from an early age, adults who use two languages every day, or pupils learning a foreign language at school? Results for one group do not automatically apply to another.
  2. What was measured? "Concentration", "intelligence" and "flexibility" are broad words; real research measures with a specific task, and many measures of executive function give results that do not agree with each other.
  3. How was it designed? A comparison of two existing groups, a study following people over time, or an experiment with random assignment? Two existing groups may differ in income, culture and parents' education.
  4. Has it been replicated, and what do meta-analyses say? A single study, especially with a small sample, is not enough; on this topic, meta-analyses that correct for publication bias are the sources to prioritise.

These four questions do not require reading the original paper; the source only needs to give the author's name, the year and where it was published so you can look it up. A claim that cannot answer any of the four should be treated as unchecked.

Frequently asked questions

Does learning a foreign language as a teenager count as being bilingual?

It depends on the definition. Many researchers consider anyone who uses two languages regularly in daily life to be bilingual, regardless of when they learned. But studies on cognitive benefits usually measure people who use two languages every day for many years, which is different from learning a foreign language for a few hours a week.

Why do scientists disagree so sharply about the bilingual advantage?

Because the effect, if it exists, is very small and easily masked by differences in family background, culture and education; the measures of executive function do not measure the same thing; and publication bias tilts the published literature towards positive results. These conditions make the debate hard to settle.

Does bilingualism make children slower to talk or confused between languages?

Current evidence shows that it does not cause language disorders. Bilingual children may have a smaller vocabulary in each language than monolingual children of the same age, but their total vocabulary across the two languages is comparable. Mixing words from the two languages is a normal feature of bilinguals, not confusion.

Is learning Chinese and English at the same time too much for my child?

Research does not show that learning several languages at once is harmful, but your child's time is limited. The two languages share the available hours, so each one progresses more slowly. Many families choose to focus on one language until it is solid before adding a second.

Are the results on dementia reliable?

They show a signal but no conclusion yet. Some studies in several countries have found a similar pattern; others have not. The data are mainly observational, so it is hard to separate the effect of bilingualism from accompanying factors such as education, occupation and migration background.

Should we choose a course because it promises to make our child smarter?

That should not be the main reason. The cognitive benefits of bilingualism are a disputed topic, and they do not apply to short courses. Choose a course based on the quality of teaching, the amount of practice, safety and how well it fits your child's language goals.

Need specific advice for your case?

We will contact you within 24 hours.

Request consultation now

Related articles

Need more help?

Leave your details and we will get back to you within 24 hours.